I like all the ideas and support most of them.
Just like No1sangel said, if you give the player a random box and it shits on them they would most likely just quit.
As for chaotics that would just ruin the server IMO because it would downgrade the price of whip and tentacle even further.
The donator ranks would be a good addition to the server. Rich people who don't PVM anymore and don't use the benefits of gold membership would maybe like a nice symbol next to their name. You should make a poll for this tbh.